Does the ASMedia USB4 controller requires a PCIe x4 connection?

kmgrant.69

New member
Joined
Apr 1, 2017
Messages
4
I have a question about the ASMedia USB4 controller? I'm having a conversation with someone on another forum about the USB4 ASMedia controller as to whether or not there is lane sharing when it comes to the ASMedia controller for USB4. The guy I'm have a conversation said this.
The controller requires a PCIe x4 connection which can be wired from the CPU using one of the two M.2 dedicated x4 or from chipset.

You can't have USB 4 without PCIe lanes.
AMD didn't change the chipset/chipsets or CPU I/O block so lane count remained the same.

This isn't a case of something for nothing since nothing hardware side changed.

You lose four PCIe lanes to gain USB 4.

Is this true or not? I thought that if there was any type of lane sharing it would have to state it in the manual of the motherboard for the X870 boards. The only lane sharing in the manual that I see if for the M.2_2 which shares bandwidth with the PCIe x16 lane. I mean I've read manuals on the X870E boards from three different manufacturers, MSI, Gigabyte and Asrock and none of them state that you lose a lane or that a lane is shared with a PCIe slot while using USB4.

I should be getting my X870E Carbon WiFi motherboard tomorrow. I did have the Gigabyte X870E Aorus Pro but sent it back due to issues with one of the DIMM slots. Can anyone help me with this? TIA
 
Last edited:
The CPU cannot do lane sharing, all lanes are exclusively wired. So it's wrongly worded to speak of lane sharing. As you said, the only lane sharing is going on here:

Screenshot 2024-10-20 at 21-32-10 MPGX870ECARBONWIFI_English.pdf.png


If we look at the block diagram, we see that the ASMedia ASM4242 has four PCIe lanes permanently reserved for it.

Screenshot 2024-10-20 at 21-30-21 MPGX870ECARBONWIFI_English.pdf.png


This is due to AMD's inexplicable requirement for the X800-series platform to always reserve four lanes for the ASMedia USB 4 chip:

Screenshot 2024-10-20 at 21-41-03 Features und Layout (1) - Seite 2 - Hardwareluxx.png


So, this is not lane sharing, this is just permanently taking up four PCIe lanes, which could otherwise be used for an M.2 slot.
No normal PCIe slots lose any lanes from this.


I did have the Gigabyte X870E Aorus Pro but sent it back due to issues with one of the DIMM slots.

Often times on such a socket it can be a couple bent pins, also see here. The DIMM slots are far more robust than the delicate little pins in the CPU socket.
 
So, this is not lane sharing, this is just permanently taking up four PCIe lanes, which could otherwise be used for an M.2 slot.
No normal PCIe slots lose any lanes from this.
OK I guess he was correct then by saying you lose four PCIe lanes to gain USB 4?
 
Back
Top