Trolling?
I am merely saying that your scenario is highly unlikely.
You are telling me you purchased a retail key directly from Microsoft which you could not activate, so then some other totally unrelated key was brought over from a different system instead.
This really is highly unlikely.
So it either didn't happen or you were trying to use the key with an incorrect version of windows... which is user error.
But typically this would also be resolved by contacting support
not sure if you're trolling, but you def seem to be suffering from the "if I've never experienced it, it must not be real" attitude that seems like is becoming more and more pervasive in society these days.
I've experienced this multiple times now after bios updates on at least two MSI intel boards, including yesterday. I can also easily reproduce it on my z590, that has dual bios, if I just switch to the other bios. switching back and trying to reactivate does not resolve it.
so I agree with some others, there's something in the bios that's being used for the activation hash, that's changing after bios updates. activation failure seems to happen an hour or so later, as mine was fine when I initially booted into windows after last update. then today it showed broken.
also seems to break xbox login and windows mail app logins
all my licenses are also legit, though mine are pretty old, dating back to win 7 or 8, and upgraded over time.
the first time I ran into this, the "I changed my hardware" didn't work and I had to call MS. while selecting the default computer during reactivation didn't work, MS's solution was for me to just pick one of my other computers to reactivate, and that worked, without apparently breaking activation on the other computer I'd selected.
since then, I've done that myself when it happened again, and today, I was able to just reselect the default computer it gave me, and it reactivated without issue.
like I think a couple others mentioned, I now seem to have multiples of the same machine in my MS account device list, though don't want to delete any of them, as I'm not sure if that would actually delete any of the licenses stored in my account.
when I first noticed this, the first time I ran into it and called MS, I asked about that, and the person on the phone actually didn't know if deleteing any of the duplicates would make me lose any of my licenses, so seems like even they don't know how this all works.